2. How does it fit with Compass’ core beliefs of equality, solidarity, democracy, freedom, sustainability and well being?
Abolish corporation tax. Instead, make all UK businesses pay an ad valorem tax on their UK turnover, at lowest possible rate. (Optional lower rates for small/medium businesses). Abolish all special reliefs. Result - a fairer, simpler business tax system to replace the present complex, arbitrary, unequal system which has made taxation voluntary for large, multi-national companies.
3. How does it build the institutions of social democracy, like social groups and collective and cooperative forms of ownership and control?
Simplicity and fairness in the tax system are essential building blocks of social democracy.
4. How much will it cost or raise and where will any cost come from?
The simplified system should yield great administrative savings to the tax authorities and business alike (although there will need to be special arrangements for intra-group transactions to prevent a build-up of cascade tax). The yield will depend on the rate chosen - but tax base will be much greater than corporation tax (all businesses trading in UK, not just those in profit).
5. Which groups in the electorate are likely to support or oppose this measure? Is there any polling evidence you have on this?
Loss-making businesses will complain at paying tax. Answer - they do this already, through VAT and uniform business rate. (And loss-making businesses use public services as much as those in profit). Profitable businesses could get big tax reductions and small/medium businesses could gain. All businesses gain from simplicity of new system.
6. Is there a place or country where it’s worked? Please provide some information.
Not to my knowledge. This is a fundamental change.
7. What are the three main arguments in favour/against it?
Fairness and simplicity. Present complexity helps big businesses who can afford smart accountants.
Greater ease of collection and certainty of revenue. Far harder for businesses to reduce or conceal UK turnover than profits. Attacks tax evasion by multi-nationals.
Economic efficiency - no penalty on businesses for being profitable and elimination of incentives to business to make decisions for tax reasons.
-
Racheal
How will this clos tax loop holes? will there not simply be more ways to get around it? perhaps instead we should focus simply on closing the loop holes and tax havens?
-
David Chester
I believe that any kind of tax on the products of production be it on personal income, on purchases or on the “profits” from business is daylight robbery. The right to tax anything rests with the government but they must be shown that what the effect of this tax does is harm to the rate of prosperty that would otherwise follow.
In order for the government to still have an income it is much better if they take from land owners the opportunity cost that the land owners (and speculators) are taking from the community, by their holding of the land (even if it is being used). This value is largely due to the infrastructure due to government investmet of tax-payers money and population density, where people prefer to live and work together. As a tax payer I want some interest on my investment and if this were used for further government expenses my personal taxes could be reduced if not eliminated.
Thus we should tax takings and not makings.
-
That was a great blog. Most blogs are not even worth reading.
-
Are you planning to blog more on this topic. I would like to learn more.
-
adrianpotts
This is certainly an interesting idea with definite promise. I feel it is still not perfect, but the current system of corporation tax is a mess. This may be a considerable improvement. It would be harder (though not impossible) to avoid, less susceptible to manipulation by accountants, and more transparent. There are other taxes that could be considered as well though along side this tax. Companies could be taxed in proportion to the remuneration they pay to their directors, or the amount they pay in dividends to shareholders. That could act as a break on director pay, and encourage re-investment.
-
Nice Site. I will be visiting more often as you have done a good job.

The default "Block" is always the title block for the post, that is where general comments are posted:

To comment on any "Block" within a post, click on the comments bar next to that block:

To view comments about a "Block" within a post, click on the yellow comment indicator next to that block:

February 10th, 2009 at 11:57 pm
That was a great blog. Most blogs are not even worth reading.
February 10th, 2009 at 11:59 pm
Are you planning to blog more on this topic. I would like to learn more.
March 10th, 2009 at 2:29 pm
Nice Site. I will be visiting more often as you have done a good job.