2. How does it fit with Compass’ core beliefs of equality, solidarity, democracy, freedom, sustainability and well being?
All of the above Now, more than ever, we need council housing. The free-market approach to housing policy has utterly failed, leaving millions of people to suffer. Decent housing is a human right and council housing is the best way to provide it because it is democratic and sustainable in a way that no other tenure is. As such, it promotes equality, freedom and well-being. Millions of British people benefited from council housing in the 20th century, we must not deny it to the next generation in the 21st.
3. How does it build the institutions of social democracy, like social groups and collective and cooperative forms of ownership and control?
Council housing, by its very nature, is intrinsically linked to social democracy. The proud history of the tenants’ movement demonstrates that council housing fosters genuine community participation and involvement. Council housing is owned by the community and can be controlled via the ballot box.
4. How much will it cost or raise and where will any cost come from?
Council housing is already self-financing, but can be made better for the 21st century with a level of public investment at a fraction of the cost of policy alternatives. The multi-billion pound attempts to salvage the property market are not only hugely expensive, they don’t work. £2 billion would enable the building of thousands of genuinely affordable and sustainable homes, with a revenue flow in perpetuity, while saving £ billions in housing benefit, health care, energy costs and environmental damage - and giving decent jobs to thousands.
5. Which groups in the electorate are likely to support or oppose this measure? Is there any polling evidence you have on this?
This is a policy that doesn’t need a focus group. Whenever people are asked the question in an unloaded way, they express their support for council housing - now more than ever. There are 4 million people living in council housing and up to 5 million on waiting lists, with more joining the queue every day as the result of repossessions. The demand for new council housing is supported by all the major trade unions and has been endorsed overwhelmingly at Labour Party conferences. That’s a mandate.
6. Is there a place or country where it’s worked? Please provide some information.
It’s worked in the UK. In the USA, the failure to build decent public housing has been an economic and social disaster and this sad truth will continue to be demonstrated in the years to come. The fact that Britain has a proud tradition of a right to decent housing within the the mainstream of the welfare state gives us a head-start. We can rebuild it!
7. What are the three main arguments in favour/against it?
1. Relieve housing need and all the social problems that result from homelessness and poor housing conditions.
2. Inject some balance and rationality into the madness of the property market.
3. Build homes that can genuinely contribute to climate change reduction.
-
simon canning
The original german system was nearly 100% social housing. Funnily enough, the right-to-buy (or a similar system) was introduced when the Berlin wall came down and soviet control was lost. Of course the soviet side was full of incredibly badly designed housing (almost identical to the social housing that is left in britain). Social problems from social housing dwellers only started to build up in the old soviet sectors. This is what has happened to the UK system in my belief. People become the scapegoats of bad design.
-
simon canning
It worked well in Germany!
-
simon canning
The middle classes in this country have all assumed they are the only ones who want more than what they paid for for their housing. They have not paid attention to the fact that there is no code-of-conduct or design rule to housing, either for rent or purchase. They have not argued for it (as it would lower housing that is known to be bad quality). This self-centered approach has created all of our housing problems.
Basically, if they don’t like it, tough.
-
simon canning
this is fine, providing the quality of insulation (sound proofing, heat-proofing and “feel”) is good.
otherwise the same old problems will appear.
-
simon canning
most social housing is still poorly designed, imprivate, inpersonal and expensive to heat/clean as a result of the poor design.
this does not help homelessness. it just keeps the people off the streets as such.
-
If the government would permit councils the same financial facillities as housing associations, there would be no need whatsoever for there to be a shortage of truly affordable homes. Grants are available to support the construction of environmentally friendly homes, councils are more likely to follow this route than private developers in the current financial climate.
-
David Flint
What’s the policy? To build more - but how many more? How fast? Just being pro Council Housing isn’t a policy!
-
Truly excellent and timely campaign. We are in good company with others in NW Europe who are getting organised to recover their municipal housing traditions or to move closer towards council or other forms of democratic housing. Fine swiss and Austrian examples too. The case for this is overwhelming. Talk prepared for a german audience is on my blog and I would value comments. Michael

The default "Block" is always the title block for the post, that is where general comments are posted:

To comment on any "Block" within a post, click on the comments bar next to that block:

To view comments about a "Block" within a post, click on the yellow comment indicator next to that block:

December 19th, 2008 at 11:39 am
What’s the policy? To build more - but how many more? How fast? Just being pro Council Housing isn’t a policy!
December 19th, 2008 at 1:24 pm
Truly excellent and timely campaign. We are in good company with others in NW Europe who are getting organised to recover their municipal housing traditions or to move closer towards council or other forms of democratic housing. Fine swiss and Austrian examples too. The case for this is overwhelming. Talk prepared for a german audience is on my blog and I would value comments. Michael